|
From
TNPC issue #3.09...
Palm Pilots and Serial Problems
by Al Gordon
April 27, 2000
One more visit to the fried Palms controversy: I arranged to
speak with a senior technology expert at Palm Inc. about my
problems with blown-out serial ports.
The story from their side is this--yes, there have been reported
problems, but no, they do not think they are Palm problems.
Rather, the issue is the design of serial ports themselves.
Basically, you have a metal port connecting to a metal terminal
on a metal wire cable, connected at the other end to more metal
contacts for the Palm and its cradle, or any other device. In the
absence of heavy-duty grounding, when you bring a static electric
charge into contact with any of that metal, it's likely to cook
something--and that something most likely is the interface
between the serial port and the motherboard.
While I agree with Palm's explanation that this can happen with
almost any serial device, I would note that most serial devices--
external modems, for instance--are designed to be connected once
and usually just left connected. Palm organizers, however, are
designed to be repeatedly pulled in and out of the cradle to be
synchronized or recharged. So perhaps the company could have done
a little bit more in the grounding department.
In any case, there is a relatively simple solution. Don't use the
serial port.
Palm makes a USB converter, which will work in Windows 98 (and
they promise drivers eventually for Windows 2000). Or--my
solution--Belkin (among others) makes USB hubs that include
serial ports. My Belkin hub is Windows 2000 capable (download the
Windows 2000 drivers from Belkin's web site; don't use the
Windows 98 drivers shipped with the hub). In use, the Belkin
device's ports are indistinguishable from a system serial port,
which allows any serial device to work in Windows 2000.
Check out all of Belkin's solutions here:
http://www.TheNakedPC.com/t/309/tr.cgi?palm1
The Belkin F5U012 USB Express BUS Plus Multi Port Hub at Amazon:
http://www.TheNakedPC.com/t/309/tr.cgi?palm2
USB is designed for hot-swapping and heavier current loads than
serial connections. Besides, my theory is that the next errant
static electric discharge will have to cook the USB hub before it
can get to my motherboard.
Or so I hope.
You can reach Al Gordon at:
mailto:algordon@TheNakedPC.com
Copyright © 2000, PRIME Consulting Group, Inc. and Dan Butler.
All Rights Reserved.
The Naked PC is a trademark of PRIME Consulting Group, Inc.
ISSN: 1522-4422
You may reprint an article from TNPC as long as you show the
entire article and include the authors byline, excerpt and
subscription information as shown:
Palm Pilots and Serial Problems
by Al Gordon
(This article originally appeared in The Naked PC
newsletter #3.09, subscribe at http://www.TheNakedPC.com)
|