Computer news you will use...

 
This is supplemental information to the article:

FireWire Meets USB 2.0

 

by Al Gordon

So here we are having gotten used to USB and starting to think about adopting FireWire when along comes USB 2.0. Now what?

How about having your cake and eating it, too?

Adaptec, the leader in SCSI technology, has unveiled an extensive lineup of both FireWire and USB 2.0 products, headlined by the DuoConnect combo PCI card for desktop computers ($116).The combo card provides three USB 2.0 ports and two for FireWire.

Adaptec also makes desktop cards that are solely USB 2.0 or FireWire. But unless you have two PCI slots to spare I strongly recommend the combo card because you are likely to need support for both technologies in the months ahead.

Since notebook cards are hot-swappable, there isn't the same need for a dual card. Nor is there enough real estate on a credit card-sized card to provide that many ports. Adaptec's solutions here are the three-port FireConnect for Notebooks ($90) and a two-port USB2connect for Notebooks.

The reason both come into play is that the standards have been adopted by different market segments. FireWire support was built into Windows XP, and Microsoft is due to release an XP update for USB 2.0.

FireWire originally was Apple"s trademark for what is officially known as "IEEE 1394" -- a designation so catchy that is no wonder FireWire became the generic term. It provides data transfers of up to 400 mbps (megabits per second) and is becoming the interface of choice for digital video and multimedia components such as digital video recorders and cameras.

USB 2.0 (also called "Hi-Speed USB 2.0") supports data transfers of up to 480 mbps, compared with 12 mbps on current USB v. 1.1 devices. It is being adopted in the PC world for data storage related devices, such as external hard drives and tape drives. 2.0 is backwards compatible, so your older USB devices will still connect (although, of course, only at 1.1 speeds). Happily, attaching an older, slower peripheral to a USB 2.0 hub does not slow down the faster components. The two versions will co-exist and run at their own speeds.

Adaptec has taken advantage of this in designing some slick XHubs for USB (so you can attach more peripherals to your card), with up to seven ports. The four and seven port "plus" models come with a wire stand designed to allow you to route cables neatly.

Note the orange graphics in the above photo. That's actually a spot under a clear plastic cover designed to hold a 2"x 2" photo. Snap off the metal "frame" (where the Adaptec logo is), and then put your photo in there, and you can disguise your hub as a picture frame. A nice touch if the XHub is sitting on your desk.

Both FireWire and USB 2.0 allow for plug-and-play, hot-swappable device connections. Given that they can exceed the data transfer rates of older generation SCSI and are more simple to configure, FireWire and USB 2.0 are likely to eventually displace SCSI as the leading technology for high-bandwidth external peripherals.

As it happens, Adaptec recently has released new drivers and a firmware (the software embedded on the device) upgrade for its USBXchange adapter ($75).

A sleek cable with a USB connector on one end and SCSI connectors on the other, USBXchange will allow you to plug low-bandwidth legacy SCSI peripherals -- scanners and Zip drives, for instance -- into a USB port. The target is the class of external SCSI devices made before Windows fully supported USB and, thus, SCSI was the best available option at the time.

In its original incarnation, USBXchange only supported USB 1.0. It now gives full 1.1 performance, which is more than adequate. My old SCSI Zip 250 is running like a charm. The adapter can give your legacy peripherals plug-and-play convenience, and help you save SCSI for devices that really need them.

Not that Adaptec is backing away from SCSI in the least. SCSI is still faster -- up to 160 MBps (megabytes per second, roughly 1,280 mbps, or three times FireWire/USB 2.0 speeds). It also can maintain higher sustained data transfer rates than other standards and still is the way to go for high performance hard drives. Adaptec has updated drivers and firmware to provide XP compatibility for it family of workhorse SCSI cards:

 

19160 -- Designed for general PC use, it will support LVD 160 MBps devices (the fast current SCSI technology) internally, and gives external support to legacy devices up to 20 mbps.

 

29160 -- Provides a circuit for internal and external 160 MBps. LVD devices, and internal support for legacy SCSI up to 40 mbps. This combination will work for workstations and some servers.

 

39160 -- The top of the line unit, it has two 160 MBps channels. Because SCSI chains only go as fast as the slowest SCSI device on a channel, this gives you the option of handling legacy devices internally and externally plus the high speed devices internally and externally.

In addition, the company has announced it has developed a 320 MBps version of SCSI -- no products yet because most of today's computers couldn't keep up -- with a 640 technology being researched.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You can reach Al Gordon at:

mailto:al@TheNakedPC.com

 

Return to Top

 
TNPC Hot Tips:
  • To contact the staff of The Naked PC, call 800-565-7069.

  • If you have a Web page you can add our new animated icon and proclaim yourself a proud member of the Naked Horde! Just click here and cut and paste the necessary HTML code.

  • PRIME for Office Utilities CD is NOW AVAILABLE for only 49.95! Get DocLauncher (for Office 2000 and Office XP), as well as PRIME for Word and PRIME for Excel utility sets (for Office 97, Office 2000, and Office XP). Included is our free, full-text searchable, 118 page ebook How to Save Time with Office that tells you exactly how to use each of these utilities to save yourself time and angst when trying to get Microsoft Office to do your bidding. Click here for information and to order this utility CD.

  • You can now order our e-book The Book That Should Have Come with Your Computer! Get yours now.